Quick answer: PC Gamer’s November 19 hands-on discovery found an item called the Genuine Cowboy Hat for $5 at a yard sale in Port Gellhorn. Its appearance closely resembles Arthur Morgan’s hat from Red Dead Redemption 2. That resemblance makes it a strong reported Rockstar crossover Easter egg, but Rockstar has not separately confirmed a formal ‘Arthur Morgan hat’ item designation.
Where is the yard sale in Port Gellhorn?
- Travel to Port Gellhorn on Leonida’s west coast, in Kelly County.
- Look toward the southern end of the town, in the small residential cluster northwest of the Dirt Merchants mod shop. PC Gamer describes around five houses in the area.
- Watch roadside notices advertising a Yard Sale, some with balloon decorations. Follow the signs into the neighborhood.
- Look for a driveway crowded with household items, an American flag, balloons and a cowboy-themed cardboard cutout.
- Among the objects in the sale, find a couch with a guitar case. The Genuine Cowboy Hat is reportedly resting on the case.
- Use the sale interaction and check the current in-game price. PC Gamer paid $5 in its run.
What does the hat look like?
The accessory looks similar to Arthur Morgan’s signature cowboy hat in Rockstar’s earlier western game, including recognizable shape and detailing. The item appears under the generic in-game product name Genuine Cowboy Hat, not a licensed Arthur Morgan cosmetic pack. This is an editorial comparison, not a confirmed lore statement connecting the two game worlds.
What if the yard sale isn’t there?
The source’s directions identify the small neighborhood and props rather than an official collectible-map icon or coordinate. If the sale is missing, try returning at another time and check for its balloons and roadside sign. Whether the yard sale runs on a fixed schedule or can spawn elsewhere has not been verified; avoid repeatedly reloading based on invented odds.
Is this needed for 100% completion?
There is no verified indication that buying this outfit item contributes to the mandatory collectible totals, the story mission count or a unique Red Dead 2 questline. It is useful primarily for visual customization and Easter egg hunting. See our clothes and outfit storage guide and collectibles directory for different systems.
FAQ: Is it the exact hat Arthur Morgan wore?
PC Gamer calls it a familiar-looking RDR2 accessory, but the published evidence establishes appearance and location, not an official item identity or narrative link. Describe it as an Arthur Morgan-style hat, not an authenticated shared-universe artifact.
Primary source: PC Gamer firsthand discovery, November 19, 2026. This is original editorial synthesis of an attributed playthrough, not an independent site playtest or reproduced source screenshots.






