Spoiler warning: Chapter 3, mission Dubious Provenance. Short answer: Handing the bronze statue to art dealer Benedict Halifax is the faster choice if you intend to finish the mission. Refusing at first does not create a permanently separate storyline; you can hold onto it, but you eventually have to return and hand it over to continue. PC Gamer’s playthrough found no significant lasting branch from this initial refusal.
When does the Halifax choice appear?
The relevant objective occurs in Dubious Provenance, described as the fourth Chapter 3 story mission in PC Gamer’s ordering. After Cal visits the Bayside apartment borrowed from Boobie and inspects the hard drive, a statuette icon appears at the closet. Jason and Lucia obtained the bronze object earlier in Chapter 1. Inspect it to start the errand, then drive to Capri and visit the antiques business.
What happens if you give Halifax the statue?
- At the Capri antiques shop, Evelyn Andrews refuses to buy the apparently stolen artwork.
- Dealer Benedict Halifax approaches and offers to evaluate it. Agree to hand it over.
- Halifax gives you a watch as collateral during the supposed appraisal.
- He later becomes difficult to reach, and you must follow up with calls to track him down and resolve the errand.
What happens if you keep the statue instead?
Declining lets you retain it temporarily, but the story’s objective does not turn into a separate confirmed long-term reward. According to PC Gamer’s test, the player must return to Capri later and give Halifax the statue to continue that mission path. The practical cost of refusing is extra travel and time rather than escaping the dealer’s storyline.
Best choice by goal
| Your goal | Suggested choice |
|---|---|
| Finish the story mission with least backtracking | Give Halifax the statue now |
| Role-play a cautious character | Keep it temporarily, accepting another return trip |
| Keep a permanent unique collectible | No verified alternate keep-forever completion path |
Will it change the ending or your Criminal Profile?
The tested source does not document a distinct ending, permanent dealer replacement, extra cash outcome or profile-rank change from this first decision. Do not interpret the absence of an observed branch as proof that no other dialogue changes are possible; it simply means those effects have not been verified. For the difference between temporary decisions and the broader system, see GTA VI Criminal Profile.
What if Dubious Provenance won’t start?
Confirm you reached the relevant Chapter 3 Bayside apartment sequence with Cal, and look for the statuette interaction at the closet. If there is no marker, check story progress and current mission availability before assuming a bug. Use a manual save before major story events; see saving precautions.
Source: PC Gamer hands-on choice guide, published November 19, 2026. This is independently written synthesis, not The Leonida Scene firsthand gameplay. The featured image is not a mission-specific screenshot.

